Venture capitalist Bruce Booth has moved his blog over to the Forbes network, and in his latest post he has some solid advice for people who are preparing to pitch him (and people like him) some ideas for a new company. It’s very sensible stuff, including the need to bring as much solid data as you can possibly bring, not to spend too much time talking about how great everyone on your team is, and not to set off the hype detectors. (Believe it, everyone who’s dealt with early-stage biotech and pharma has a very sensitive, broad-spectrum hype detector, and the “off” switch stopped working a long time ago).
He also has some advice that might surprise people who haven’t been watching the startup industry over the last few years: “Unless you are really convinced you have a special story that Wall Street will love, please don’t use that three-letter word synonymous with so much value destruction: I-P-O.” That’s the state of things these days, for better or worse – the preferred exit strategy is to do a good-sized deal with a larger company, and most likely to be bought outright.
And this is advice that I wish that more seminar speakers would follow, not just folks pitching a company proposal:
It’s annoying when an entrepreneur touting a discovery-stage cancer program has multiple slides on how big the market is for cancer drugs, what the sales of Avastin were last year, what the annual incidence of the big four cancers are, etc… These slides give me a huge urge to reach for my Blackberry. We know cancer is huge. Unless you’ve got a particular angle on a disease or market that’s unique or unappreciated, don’t bother wasting time on the macro metrics of these diseases, especially when you’re in drug discovery.
Yes indeed, and that goes for anyone who’s talking outside the range of their expertise. If you’re giving a talk, it should be on something that you know a lot about – more than your audience, right? So why do we have to sit through so many chemists talking about molecular biology, molecular biologists talking about market size, and so on? My rule on that stuff is to hold it down to one slide if possible, and to skip through it lightly even then. I’ve even seen candidates come in for an interview and spend precious time, time that could be spent showing what they can do and why they should be hired, on telling everyone things that they already know and don’t care to hear again.